Some years ago I wrote about a nominally Spanish pen brand by the name of
Presidente. Then, a fellow stylophile in Greece contacted me apropos of a similar pen sold in the Greek market under the name
Joker.
A fruitful conversation ensued, and we reached to a couple of tentative conclusions:
– Joker was presumably a Greek company, or based in Greece, as opposed to being Italian, as its advertisement in Greece had suggested.
–
Hifra, another brand marketing similar pens, was likely to be South African.
From top to bottom, a Joker, a Hifra, and a Presidente. But all of them are, actually, Platinum.
Now, how sure can we be of those conclusions? We can safely say that Presidente was Spanish because there are records fo such a brand registered in Madrid, Spain, in 1959; but we do not know of similar registries in Greece or in South Africa.
However, we have other information—Joker as a brand seems unknown outside Greece and, interestingly enough, in Italy, while there was some
Joker ink in Greece as well. Hifra, on its side, seemed like a domestic name in some
South African texts. Therefore, in absence of contradicting information I feel that those conclusions were reasonable.
Joker ink, in Greece. Photo by Kostas K.
The problem here is to decide which sources are reliable. And that in a field where most of us are aficionados with no pay, with other obligations, and with not many resources to do any research.
So, who is reliable and who is not?
We are not living in an academic environment and we do not have peer-reviewed journals to publish our findings. Consequently we must rely on the good or bad name each of us created along the years through our contributions to the community. And the rest is up to the receiver.
Some weeks ago,
Inky.Rocks published
a video on the ink Pilot Blue-black, about which I had spoken
on these pages. Inky.Rocks pointed out that this ink is water resistant by reacting with the cellulose in the paper. This claim was challenged on
Reddit, and that was good. The problem was that the challenger did not offer any alternative to the behavior of the Pilot ink, nor any reason why Noodler's should be the only maker with cellulose-reacting inks.
What vintage do you prefer for your Blue-black?
Pilot Blue-black ink is water resistant. That I can prove. The sample was one full minute under running water. Some dyes were removed from the iron-gall inks. The modern formulation, cellulose reacting, is remarkably resistant to water.
At the end of the day, the facts are that Pilot Blue-black is a water resistant ink without being iron-gall or pigmented. And that a former Pilot worker, well respected in the Japanese pen community, explained the change in the formulation of the Pilot Blue-black ink in the 1990s to whoever wanted to listen.
Are those arguments conclusive? Certainly not. But they are better than nothing.
And that is why critical sense is so important.
Pilot Capless LS – Pilot Iroshizuku Yama-budo
Bruno Taut
Nakano, June 23rd, 2020
etiquetas: tinta, Presidente, Pilot, Joker, Hifra, Pilot, metabitácora, Platinum